Theme. Whether we realize it or not, it’s the backbone of our stories. It’s what sets them apart; what makes the reader care. It’s what gives our stories meaning; makes them stick. Even stories meant purely for entertainment have some kind of theme.

It’s intuitive to the storyteller in a writer. Stories show how people change themselves or their environment. Some stories are purposely meant to teach a lesson. While there shouldn’t always be an obvious “moral of the story” (because that can get cheesy) there’s always an underlying theme.
Why You Should Plan Theme
With theme comes power. Whatever your theme is, it’s your take on the world. How your characters are rewarded and punished for acting certain ways, the plot moves forward and gets more complicated, and scenarios play out shows what your theme is meant to show. Even in a plot-driven story, there’s theme in practically everything. We must learn to take advantage of it. It’ll be there whether you like it or not.
Even if you don’t consider yourself a plotter, if there’s one thing you should plan before you write, it’s theme. Theme is at the heart of your characters and your plot. If you want to make the most of it, you must plan ahead, simply because of its nature. It’s harder to edit in theme than it is to plan it out.
TL;DR: Theme is very, very important.
Plus, when you plan theme, you have more opportunities to incorporate themes in multiple aspects of your story, without having to completely rework it. And of course, when you know your theme while pantsing, you can come up with natural ways to enhance your theme as you write.
However, if this doesn’t work for you at all (hey, everyone writes their own way!), you can also use this is a guide to edit theme into your story if you’ve written it and it’s not quite developed. If you do this or have another method, share in the comments! I’d love to hear what works for you.
Step One: Brainstorm
You shouldn’t necessarily go with the first theme that comes to mind. There are many ways you can use theme in any given story, so make sure you’re choosing the theme that will work best with the plot and have maximum impact on the reader.
First: think about your passions. What ideas do you hold to be true? What advice do you often give to those who are younger or less experienced than you? “Write what you know” is most important in theme. Being passionate about and having human experience with a theme will make it more genuine.
Then, compare themes that you are passionate about to themes that will work with your story. Look at where the two lists match up. Those are the themes you will want to consider for your story.
Step Two: Develop
Story theory can be pretty complicated here. However, here’s the basic rundown:
Main character believes in and acts on a false idea, and in order for his situation to improve, he must believe in or act on a true idea, which seems unappealing or unbelievable.
If this intrigues you, read books like Story by Robert McKee, Dramatica, or Creating Character Arcs by K.M. Weiland. However, that’s the main principle of theme as it relates to plot and character. As you can see, theme is intertwined with both. Think about how your characters act and what happens to them. How does every scene reflect the lies and truths that exist within your theme? Where can you see the truth and lie at work?
It’s important to note; however, that you shouldn’t try to “play God” in a sense — similar to duex ex machina endings. Things shouldn’t “just happen” because your character was good or bad. He shouldn’t get the new job he wants because he’s nice to his family now, nor should he have it rain out on an important event because he was rude. Actions should have reasonable consequences. For example, the classic “guy interviewing for a job was rude to the lady at the front desk who ended up being his interviewer” situation.
Step Three: Implement and Enhance
Once you’ve come up with your basic theme, its truth and lies, and how it should generally affect the plot, you can implement the theme to your plot. If you enjoy lots of plotting, work the theme into every scene. If you don’t like to plot much, write a list of key turning points and actions that affect the plot.
It’s important to make theme as realistic to life as possible. Explore every gray area. Don’t let the reader necessarily know what’s right and wrong; allow them to explore it within the story. Know how traumatic events affect people, and how fast or slow it takes someone to completely change.
At this point, you should be able to give a short summary of your plot as it relates to the theme. From there, dive deeper. Work this into your outline, keep notes as you write to keep you on track, or edit these things in.
Small Ways to Enhance Theme
One of my favorite ways is to have the side characters believe different variations of lies according to the same or a similar truth the protagonist is facing. Think of it like a dystopia: everyone has different opinions on the same government. This keeps your characters cohesive and helps you explore theme.
Another way is to use symbolism. Colors, figures of speech, or any type of symbol you can think of can be used to enhance your theme. Characters seeing reminders of who they used to be can show just how much they’ve changed, for better or worse.
What Makes a Theme “Unique” or “Meaningful”?
Theme will never truly be unique. Throughout the history of fiction, writers have explored many themes shown in the human experience. What makes your theme “unique” is your different way of looking at it. Most importantly, you have to use your own experience and emotions to fuel your writing, because that is the most unique thing you can contribute.
What makes a theme meaningful can be many things to different people, but here’s my take: you have to make the reader think. Don’t tell the reader flat-out what you want them to take away from the book. In fact, what they take away might not be what you even intended. But getting people to talk and think and consider? That’s what brings change to the readers. That’s what makes a book powerful. That gives a novel the power to impact society.
Conclusion
In summary, the best advice I can give you is to think and put effort into your theme. Don’t just wait for theme to find you, and don’t express your theme explicitly. If you work for it, your theme will already be much improved.

Want to a worksheet to help you use these steps to plan your novel? Click here or the image above!



